Saturday, 17 September 2011

Adam Smith: The man behind your £20 note


Look on the back of a twenty pound note; you will see a 2 dimensional rendering of a man and a line of text which says, “The Division of labour in pin manufacturing (and the great increase in quantity of work that results).”  It doesn’t sound particularly inspiring; you might be questioning whether such a discovery has a worthy place on the back of our currency. After all, pin manufacturing is not the most important of industries. But what he found has had a profound affect on the way we work, live and the role of government.


 
Why don’t we make our own things?

Why don’t we build our own houses, grow our own crops, farm our cattle, educate our own kids, design and make our own clothes? Well if we did, most of us would be living in wooden shacks, practically starving and have a fashion sense of a prehistoric man.  The reason we don’t is because it is more efficient for someone else to do it, who is specialised in a particular skill.

Adam Smith noticed in a pin factory, a group of workers who produce their own pins from start to finish were significantly less productive than a group specialising in one aspect of pin manufacturing. He estimated that by dividing labour up in a factory there would be between a 240 and 4,800 fold increase in productivity. By focusing the skill of the workers on one task, the worker was able to learn some efficiency tricks, what to do and what not to do in his specific role.

This same principle can be applied to the economy as a whole. Why do we have electricians, doctors, hairdressers etc? – it’s because specialisation increases the total amount of goods and services that we can have.

Consider this quote from Milton Friedman.


“Not one person in the world knows how to make this pencil.”

What he means is the lead (graphite) in the pencil comes from a mine in China. In that mine hundreds of miners are specialised in its extraction. The miners use tracks and tools, tools which are produced by other specialised people. The wood comes from Northern Europe, where lumberjacks work with saws made by blacksmiths. The rubber is grown from trees in Malaysia. Literally thousands of people, all specialised in their own tasks, have been required in order to produce the pencil for you in exchange for 20p.  

Such is the power of the division of labour.


The Invisible Hand

Another aspect of Adam Smiths work was the famous ‘invisible hand’.

Adam Smith was amazed by smugglers. During the 1770s, when the Wealth of Nations was written, there were heavy taxes on certain imported goods; smugglers would avoid importing these goods through the major ports to avoid this tax. It was during this observation that Adam Smith realised that although these smugglers were acting in their own interest, they were also acting in the interest of their customers. By avoiding the tax they were able to provide the goods for a lower cost. It was as if they were guided by an invisible hand.

If somebody wants an income, then they need to produce something that somebody else wants to buy. In order to promote ones own interests, they are serving the interests of his customers.

Gorden Gekko’s famous speech in the film Wall Street, said “greed is good”. And in according with Adam Smiths invisible hand, he’s right. So long as there is effective competition and the markets are working efficiently, the greedier someone is, the more they will have to produce to get it. In other words…“In competition, individual ambition, serves the common good.”


Friday, 9 September 2011

Some Clever Marketing Tricks

In traditional economics marketing was simple a means of informing potential customers about your product. An advert would state what the product does, what it can be used for and how much it costs. It might also say why it’s better than it competitors, but nowadays it has taken on a whole new entity. It has become a means of manipulating customers rather than informing them.

If you’re a private company you are going to use every trick in the book to try and boost your profits. Here are a couple of them.   


Conditioning

Ivan Pavlov, the famous Russian physiologist, found that if you feed a dog and ring a bell at the same time, the dog will begin to expect to be feed every time the bell is rang regardless of whether the food is there or not. Not only will the dog expect to be feed but it will also start salivate. Crucially, salivation is not a cognitive thought, but it is an involuntary response that has been hard coded into the dog. The process of gaining an involuntary response through repeated stimulus is known as ‘Conditioning’, and it doesn’t just apply to dogs.

If I’m a trying to sell something wouldn’t it be great to cause an involuntary response of people to buy my product. All I need to do pair the product or brand I’m selling with an involuntary feeling or response. For example if I was thirsty, what brand or product might you associated with the word ‘thirst’?


Why is Sprite saying “Obey your thirst!” in their advert? It is not informing you about how it tastes, what the price is or how it is better than its competitors. They are trying to condition you so that when you are thirsty you will think of Sprite.

If you regularly watch advertising on the telly you will bombarded by these messages. It’s quite possible that many of your purchasing decisions are not based on rational thought but involuntary responses to marketing stimuli.

Anchoring

Human beings have evolved several odd traits that were required to stay alive hundreds of thousands of years ago, but today they can cause suboptimal decision making. One of these traits is Anchoring.

In order to make quick decisions man needed to use reference points. “Is this a good cave to live in?”, “is she a good mate (in the reproductive sense)?” To answer these sorts of questions humans need reference points. They need to compare to previous caves to know if the current one is a good one (and the same is true with girlfriends).
;-p

But when it comes to making purchasing decisions, clever marketing companies can use anchoring to their advantage. Consider this advert for a subscription to the Economist.

  1. Internet only subscription $59
  2. Print-only subscription $125
  3. Print and internet subscription $125

You might think ‘why would anyone want to buy 'Print only subscription' and that ‘the Economist must have either made a mistake or be a bit stupid?’ But actually they are using anchoring to their advantage. By placing the ‘Print only subscriptions’ at the same price as 'Print and Internet' they have forced you to anchor to number 2 and therefore make number 3 appear an excellent deal.

In the above example 84% of sales went to number 3, 0% to number 2 and 16% to number one, but when number 2 was removed sales to number 3 fell to just 32%. Buy using the decoy anchor the economist were able to increase their revenue.

Here’s another example:

1)      When Ghandi died, was he younger or older than 140?
2)      How old do you think Ghandi was when he died?   

With this line of questioning the average response to question 2 was 67 but if I change question one to: ‘When Ghandi died, was he younger or older than 9?’ the average response to question 2 was 50.

Question 1 was another decoy anchor, it was designed so that your brain took that age as the bench mark and the adjusted it.  

However once you are aware of these sales tactics you are less likely to fall for them and more likely to appreciate them. Next time your in Tunisia and a man selling a water pipe says “500 Dinar, no?... Okay for you 100” you can compliment him on his good anchoring.

Saturday, 3 September 2011

Why do we tip?


You’re in a restaurant with friends, you’ve just finished your meal, it was ok, nothing spectacular, but when it comes to pay for the bill, for some reason you pay more than it cost. Why did you do this?

For economists, tipping is an odd thing. It is often assumed that people are rational and that they will try to maximise their happiness given their limited budget. But for someone to choose to give away some of that budget unnecessarily is a confusing issue indeed.

Consumer Surplus

Whenever anybody buys something they do so because it adds more value than its price. For example if I buy an apple for 25p, I do so because I was prepared to pay up to 50p. The benefit of the apple to me is 50p. In other words I have converted 25p of currency into 50p worth of appley delight. The 25p worth of additional benefit is known in economics as Consumer Surplus.

But you wouldn’t give away Consumer Surplus to the seller of the apple voluntarily, so why do you do it in a restaurant? To answer this we need to turn to a field of economics called Institutions Economics

Institutions

Institution is a word often floated about the press but its meaning is often misunderstood. An institution is a socially accepted normal behaviour.

The Royal Family is an institution, a hand shake, a tie, queuing, a wedding and saying ‘hello’ when you greet someone are all institutions.  It is the things you do to demonstrate that you are normal person and that your behaviour is predictable.
Without institutions humans would be no different from animals, our behaviour would be erratic and civilised society would not exist.

If you think about it, shaking someone’s hand when you meet them is an odd thing indeed. We do it to demonstrate to the person you are meeting that our behaviour is predictable, that we will obey the socially accepted normal behaviour and in doing so reduce uncertainty or increase trust. If you meet someone who did not shake your hand and just stood there, you might feel uneasy and a bit awkward.

Tipping is no different, by tipping in a restaurant with you friends or girlfriend; you are demonstrating that your behaviour is normal, that you are not ‘tight’.  See the extract from Reservoir Dogs for a convincing argument.


Misallocation

Tipping does cause theoretical problems however. Tipping, particularly in the US where the institution is strongest, can cause a glut in supply or a shortage in demand. If the institution is a 10% tip of the cost of the bill then price is effectively 10% higher, this means reduced demand for and increase in the amount of people who want to become a waiter (since the tip goes exclusively to the waiter). Normally the market would correct for this by reducing the wage of the waiters, but if there is a minimum wage preventing this correction then we are left with people who want to be waiters but are unable to find a job.

The people who want to be waiters are usually young, unskilled and inexperienced. Waiting is often their chance at finding employment and gaining experience for a chance at future higher paid job.

So when you tip you are upholding an unnecessary institution, you are benefiting the waiter by reducing your own consumer surplus. But you are also indirectly hurting potential waiters by reducing their employment chances.

So next time when it comes to paying your bill, perhaps you should take a page out of Mr Pink’s book and not give one just because society tells you to. 

Sunday, 28 August 2011

University: Is it worth it?


Next year, university students will have to pay £9000 a year for tuition, but is this fair and is it still beneficial to go to university?

Uni as an investment

Despite the tripling of fees, university still adds up as a good investment. By the time you are 43 you would have earned more than someone who only completed their A levels, even though they had a three year head start (see below)*.


However, if you were to take a gap year and choose a low earning degree (art, music, media studies etc) then it simply doesn’t become a worthwhile investment.

Recently the amount the average graduate earns over their lifetime has narrowed when compared to that of a non-graduate. The reason is a simple case of supply and demand. A sluggish economy means subdued demand, plus an ever increasing amount of graduates desperate for a job means that the wage they can command will be less.

Recently there has been a strong increase in the amount of graduates applying to science, maths, medicine and of course, economics. This is because such subjects not only improve the chance of graduates being employed but also the wage they will have when they find employment. This is a direct result of recent increases in the cost of attending university.   

Fairness

Many of the recent protests regarding the increase in tuition fees are quite understandable. These students will be paying 3 times more for their degree than the previous year. It doesn’t sound very fair. But actually the tax payer has had the unfair deal for the last few decades.

Before the cuts the government would spend £7.2bn on universities, that’s £272 per household per year. When you consider that the primary beneficiaries of that money are the students themselves, it’s quite a lot. Effectively what you have is the less well off being taxed to pay for the future rich students. Certainly there are a lot of social benefits from having a more educated workforce and universities should receive subsidises from the government. However, when the student takes on so little of the cost, the result is inequitable and a waste of resources, especially when the costs go on a course which will provide little benefit to anyone.

You should go!

For students that have carefully considered their course, are self motivated and determined, university is definitely worth it. The above graph only shows the tangible financial benefit, but going to university has so many other benefits. For example living with other young, like minded people is very liberating and a lot of fun. All of those experiences at university that you cannot count certainly add value to to going.  Any graduate will tell you that the happiest days of their life were those spent at university.



* The cumulative earnings are linear as they are based on average earnings, therefore, form the data based on the graph, you cannot judge the time at which a degree would surpass the earnings of A levels

Sunday, 21 August 2011

The Lottery: 99.999999% certain it’s not going to be you


You’ve seen it in the news, all your friends are talking about it, the Euro millions jackpot is over £150m. You start to imagine what it would be like winning all that money; houses, cars, yachts and planes fill your mind. You don’t care what the odds of winning are, some has to win it and as Camelot says “it could be you!”


 Sound familiar? Then you have a classical case of probability blindness.

The human brain is not really wired to calculate things. It has evolved to catch prey, grow crops and generally make living easier. So when the chance of all up wildest dreams coming true is up for grabs the smart part of the human brain shuts down. For example take this simple maths question, which you are going to get wrong.

A bat and a ball cost £1.10 in total. The bat costs £1 more than the ball. How much does the ball cost?

Got the answer?

Even though I forewarned you about your error, you still think the answer is 10p. Don’t feel too bad, almost everyone answers this question wrong. The reason being is the brain sometimes jumps to the answer without reviewing the calculation. We often have to force ourselves to do the calculation.

So, if the ball costs 10p and the bat is £1 more, then bat is £1.10 which totals £1.20. But if the ball cost 5p and the bat is £1 more then the bat is £1.05 totalling £1.10. Not rocket science, but we have to force ourselves to do the calculation and it is the same case with the lottery. The brain thinks “there is a chance of winning £150m, the ticket only costs £2 - it’s a good deal”. We have to stop ourselves becoming emotional about the lottery, stop ourselves imagining what it would be like to win and start thinking about why we are throwing away £2 every week?

To help break through this irrationality you can use a simple tool, Expected Monetary Value (EMV), which is the probability of winning times the winning amount.

EMV

To know weather your ticket is good value or not, first you must consider the odds of winning.

To calculate this, you take the odds of guessing a single number correctly, that is 1 in 50. Guessing the next ball is slightly easier since one ball has been removed. So 1 in (50 x 49). You will need to match 5 numbers. But you don’t need to match them in any order, so you divide by the number of permutations factorial (5x4x3x2x1).

So far we have (50x49x48x47x46) / (5x4x3x2x1) = 2.1million to one

Not bad you might think, but in the Euro millions they add another set of numbers, ironically called ‘Lucky Stars’. Here you have to guess another two numbers from a pool of numbers. So an additional (11x10) / (2x1) = 55 but we are not adding we are multiplying (55x2.1milion) = 1 in 116.5million!!!!!

But the jackpot could be massive; a few weeks ago it was £166m (which it was capped to)! So is it worth it?

The EMV is the probability of wining (in decimal form) times the winning value. If the EMV is lower than the cost of the ticket, it is not a good investment.

EMV = (1/116.5million) x £166million = £1.42

The ticket cost if £2.

There are of course other prizes to be one, (not that you really care about those), if we included those it only increases the EMV to £1.80.

So the highest ever jackpot for Euro millions was still not worth buying.

There was one case where a ticket was worth buying. In 1992 some Australian investors noticed that the Virginia state lottery had an EMV of $3.95 when the ticket only cost $1.   So they quickly found 2500 investors, investing $3000 each and set about buying every possible combination of tickets. The problem they had was trying to them all in a week (they had to buy over 7 million tickets). They hired 125 people to fill out the tickets manually in stores across Virginia, but it wasn’t enough. By the time the draw went ahead the investors had only 60% of all possible combinations.  They also had another fear, what if they had to share their jackpot? In both cases the investors were massively exposed to a big loss. They watched the draw nervously, to their delight there was only one winner and it was them.

Ambition Depressor

On a concluding note, the lottery is only £2, it’s not a massive amount of money to throw away, but I do have concerns that the lottery inhibits ambition. Dale Carnegie, author of How to Win Friends and Influence people writes that one of the main hungers we have is for ‘money and things that money buys’, in other words ambition. Ambition however can be satisfied without actually encountering the money, so long as you’re moving in the right direction. For example when looking for a new job you have an ambition to move on, a hunger, but when you send off your CV to a company you feel satisfied that you are moving in the right direction. For people buying lottery tickets, I believe the hunger for ambition is being satisfied, even though there is practically no chance of winning. How many times have you herd someone who is unhappy with their job or in a bit of financial trouble part jokingly say “I’m hoping to win the lottery”? 

If everyone stopped buying lottery tickets, stopped fanaticising about the event which will never happen and instead focused on practical ways of improving their life, 99.999999% of people would be a lot better off.

Sunday, 14 August 2011

Economics of Rioting


The mass riots across our green and pleasant land have left many with a sense of disbelief and shock. The reasons behind what occurred are long and complex and most are beyond the scope of this blog, but there are some aspects that can be explained by simple economics. 


How it Started

Like many previous mass riots, the spark is usually related to race. Many young black men feel that they are discriminated against. They feel that the government and the institutions it supports are prejudiced against them. And to be fair, they have a point.

If you’re black you are 8 times more likely to be stopped and searched by police than a white person. Jermain Defoe had to get a restraining order so that Essex police stopped pulling him over ever time he drove around Essex. David Starkey, a respected Historian with a TV series on the BBC, has recently spoken on an interview regarding the riots saying “the whites have become black” as if they have caught some sort of criminal disease. So when a man was killed by police in suspicious circumstances, for the young black people of Tottenham this was a tipping point of outrage.  

The riots were intensified with false rumours sent around via Blackberry messenger saying that other black man had been killed by police, and soon similar protests erupted around London. The police gave the rioters some space, understanding that a full blown confrontation could exacerbate the situation. However neither they, nor anyone else expected the onslaught of the opportunist looter. 

The Rational Looter

When the riots in Tottenham had reached a critical mass the opportunists suddenly gained an incentive to riot.


Consider this,

Cost = Probability of being caught x Cost of being caught (including social costs)

Benefit = value of probable haul + value of emotional thrill

For most of us the cost of being caught would be horrific. We would lose our jobs, our friends and any value we appoint to our social standing. For the young, unemployed and low paid, this cost is significantly lower. They also value the haul more than we would. Many of the young crowd involved use their branded clothes, watches etc as a way of showing social status. Thirdly, many of the rioters were teenagers, who are generally emotionally volatile anyway, would find looting a greater thrill than the more mature civilian.

Generally however, a looter is no different from you or I. They will consider the benefits and costs and make a rational decision. When the police held back on engaging the rioters at first, it created an interesting affect on their cost calculations.

If we expand on the ‘Probability of being caught’, we can gain an insight into the mind of a looter.

Probability of being caught  =  (Number of police x  arrest % per officer) / Number of rioters

Before the riot we could assume to see something like this (300 * 80%)/400 = 60%
We assume a 60 % chance of being caught would not make looting a worthwhile (60% x Cost of being caught is grater than the benefit). But when the police initially held back from the rioters, the arrest % fell to a low figure say 20%.

(300 * 20%)/400 = 15%

Now looting becomes a little more attractive.

Potential looters will assign different levels of value to the haul and to the thrill of rioting, but as the number of looters increase, the probability of being caught falls. This means more and more will find looting attractive.  Imagine a 200 increase in the number of looters.

(300* 20%)/600 = 10%

This is a chain reaction, the more people start rioting the more that will find it attractive. A spiral will start with an ever falling probability of being caught. Looking at the overall cost Benefit analysis then looting becomes completely rational.

The reader might think, “I would never steal, even if the benefits outweigh the costs”. Ask yourself; have you downloaded any songs that you have not paid for? Any DVDs that are not entirely legitimate? When you stole the music or the brought the illegal DVD you did the exact same Cost-Benefit analysis as the looters.

If the government wanted to stop wide spread looting in the future it should do the following.

  1. Make sure that either police numbers are high or arrest rates are high (preferably both)
  2. Increase the cost of being caught, with stiffer sentences and larger fines.
  3. Increase the value that young people assign to their community. Currently in large cities the value young people assign is small.


Obviously there are lots of things to discuss here; I would love to hear your thoughts on the riots so please comment below.

Saturday, 30 July 2011

Stock Market Speculation

A few weeks ago a colleague of mine was telling me how he had been watching this great company and was thinking of investing in it. All the pundits had said that the stock is on the up and it was a great deal – a “strong buy” they said, but he paused mid way though his sentence and said “why would anyone sell me their stock if they knew the price was going to rise?”

He had inadvertently stumbled upon the Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH).   

The Competition

In the US 57 million households own shares out of 115 million, if we apply this logic the rest of the west there is a total of 139million people holding shares. Not all of these will be actively trading them; many will be sitting on the asset in the hope of selling it when it reaches a certain height, but a lot of them will be. The big money is controlled by hedge fund mangers, who can push and pull money around the world in an instant. They have the tools which provide them the latest information before anyone else (other non-traders), the minute a news story hits, millions of pounds are traded in an instant. They use every statistical and mathematical modelling there is to help them make the best purchasing decisions.

Often you will hear a friend say “invest in this company it’s under priced, you’ll make a fortune!” Before you do, ask them, “Do you think you have seen something that none of the 139 million traders haven’t?”

EMH

If an asset market, that has good level of liquidity (lots of buyers and sellers), the price is a perfect indicator of value. That is, the price reflects all information that is available. If the price was not truly reflective of the value of the stock, the millions of traders around the world would identify it and trade until the price did. 

Imagine a new piece of news hits the market that would cause a change in the value of the share. The price would respond almost immediately. By the time you read about it the paper the next day, the price is already fully reflective of that news story. If you were to buy the asset then, you are no longer going to gain from that particular news story. However you do have a 50:50 chance of gaining on the next story, before it comes out. This is the only way, according to the Efficient Market Hypothesis; you can beat the market and earn a short term return.

The price of an asset as an aggregate reflection of the combined wisdom of all the traders and analysts, with millions of traders speculating around the world, often disagreeing on strategy, no one trader can be expected to consistently gain over the others. When prices are not fair, they are randomly so, this means a trader will gain as much as they loose.

In short, when you think you can beat the market because you’ve heard a news story or just have a belief in a stock just remember “Trust markets, not people”. This also applies to the analyst in the papers that tell you to buy or sell a share; in this respect they are no different to an astrologist.

Animal Spirits

Like many economic theories, there is a slight problem with the EMH, humans are animals and are not entirely rational.

Humans suffer from all sorts of irrational behaviour, for example underestimating the odds of wining the lottery is common one. This irrationality also applies to the markets. Some traders hold a false belief that a stock is going to continue to rise due to cognitive biases (when holding a belief, the trader will search evidence that support that belief and ignore the evidence that does not).   

Prices can offer suffer mass distortions of value by traders not looking at the value of stock, but at what other people think the stock is worth. John Maynard Keynes (the equivalent of Jesus to economists) said “We have reached the third degree where we devote our intelligences to anticipating what the average opinion expects the average opinion to be.”

In a case of some bad news hitting the markets, traders are not looking at what the true value of a stock is, but what the average person is going to do with that stock. This creates herd type behaviour, where every shareholder runs for the exit in a mass panic with a ‘beggar thy neighbour’ mentality – Get out before anyone else does.    

Equally bubbles can form, where an assets price is massively overvalued. Because the average person believes the average person believes the stock is going to rise, it will do - in a self fulfilling prophecy.  A great example, I believe (although I suffer from cognitive biases as much as the next…) is gold. Gold historically was used for the basis of several currencies; in that respect it was an excellent store of value. Today however it is not the basis of any currency in the world. It’s only practical use is for jewellery and electrical products. However speculators believe that the average person believes that it is still a good store of value. As such, during the recent tough times, the price of gold has increased 160%. Buyers of gold believe they can sell it to a greater fool, and that greater fool believes he can sell to an even greater fool, and the bubble continues.




John Maynard Keynes lost a fortune, to what he called the ‘animal spirits’ in the markets. When a wheat was under valued he brought tonnes of it, assuning it would rise, however the rest of traders continued to sell, causing Keynes to left with tonnes of wheat that he was unable to sell .  

The list of irrational behaviours is a long one, and judging when markets will behave rational (EMH), and when it will not (animal spirits), is a difficult task.
 
If you’re thinking of investing in a stock, ask your self this – does the average opinion expect the average opinion to be rational? 

Recommended